Taylor Kinney Is (Kind Of) in a New Holiday Romcom with an Unexpected Love Interest
here’s nothing like over-the-top, corny, predictable holiday romcoms. And this year, even longtime Chicago Fire star Taylor Kinney is getting in on the action — kind of.
The star’s latest “project” was recently revealed in a December 4 Instagram post. Sure, it’s an ad, but nevertheless, it gives fans a look at an alternate universe where Kinney stars in a cheesy movie opposite WWE Superstar Nikki Garcia and The Traitors Season 4 star Donna Kelce. It’s the perfect holiday wish come true for any Kinney fan who’s been wishing for the 44-year-old to add a cheesy Christmas-themed romantic comedy to his Hollywood resume.
The “short film” has all the tropes fans would expect from a breezy holiday movie, from Bella (as the career-focused woman who moved out of her hometown for a job in the big city) literally bumping into her old boyfriend (Kinney), to the two buying each other the same Secret Santa Christmas gift.
RELATED: Chicago Fire Stars Taylor Kinney & David Eigenberg’s TikTok Fail Delights Fans
Oh, and it also includes this line: “I can’t believe I ran into my ex-boyfriend who still lives in my small hometown and he’s still so good-looking.”
Watch Taylor Kinney’s fake holiday romcom debut here.
Momma Kelce’s cameo was pitch-perfect, too. The star looked great throughout the faux film, showing the same kind of easygoing charisma that has made him a One Chicago fan favorite. Is it the greatest “movie” ever made? No. Would we watch a full-length feature film version of it solely because of Kinney? Absolutely — and fans would, too.
Ultimately, The Gift Ex-change is a harmless bit of advertising showcasing one of Chicago Fire’s longest-tenured stars. What’s not to love about that?

